The cheese, ham and jalapeno toastie from Penny's Cheese Shop in Sydney's Potts Point. The cheese Fiona says: "If you're making a plain cheese toastie, choose a sharp, stronger-tasting cheese like cheddar or a great melting cheese like swiss, gouda or gruyere. The process is simple. Here is a northerners dream toastie. But not so fast - let’s talk about those ingredients. Start with your favorite bread (gluten-free for me, please) and softened butter (check out my tips below for softening butter if you forget to leave it out). How To Make A Pizza Grilled Cheese Sandwich In The Toaster Oven. Press the other piece of bread that was left on the plate on top of the toastie. Cheese and onion pie is a true northern classic, specifically, a Lancashire classic. Spread the butter over one side of each piece of bread. And you've gotta melt the cheese! So we grate the cheese. If I see another picture of a cheese toastie where the cheese is in a piece … it drives me crazy. People are better than this." How to make a grilled cheese in the oven. When the cheese melts, remove the toastie from under the grill and place it on a plate. Use a sharp knife to do this. And absolutely, on no account, should anybody EVER add mayonnaise to a cheese toastie. Ham & cheese. I get cravings for a Cheese and onion pie at least once a week, but like everyone else, I don’t always have time to bake one. Analiese Gregory, chef and goat herd, Hobart If you’re making a simple toastie like this one, there’s no room for hiding. That is a rule for life. Here’s a great alternative; make it into a toastie! You may want to cut the toastie in to a shape you like. Two slices of bread, slice of ham, slice of cheese. In this easy cooking video, i make a grilled cheese sandwich my toaster oven. It really couldn’t be easier to knock one of these together. So try and use the best ingredients you can afford.